Shenzhen Contract Dispute: How to Break the Contract Trap and Arrears of Payment
Recently, Mr. Zhang, the boss of a technology company in Shenzhen, approached me for consultation with a furrowed brow: a payment of 8.6 million yuan was delayed by a customer for half a year, and the other party used the excuses of "unqualified product quality" and "difficult capital turnover" to impose restrictions layer by layer, and even dug up a vague clause in the original contract to pressure. This is almost the most familiar dilemma for small and medium-sized enterprises in Shenzhen. Behind such disputes over overdue payments, there are often three flaws: the contract is not signed firmly, the evidence is incomplete, and the timing is not accurate. Today, let me borrow a real case and explain these things clearly.
1、 How did the case get stuck
At the beginning of last year, a technology company in Shenzhen (pseudonym "Huachuang Intelligence") signed a supply contract with an electronic component supplier in Dongguan, with a total contract amount of 8.6 million yuan. After the goods were delivered, the other party kept delaying payment for several reasons: first, they said 'there is an installment clause in the contract', and then 'funds are tight'. The person in charge of Huachuang Intelligence searched through the contract and found that the numbers in the installment terms had been changed with a pen during the signing process, without the confirmation of the other party's official seal. No one paid attention at that time.
When they found us, their biggest concern was not the case itself, but that they wouldn't be able to get the money even if they were sentenced.Director Shen JinlongAfter the team took on the case, they first did something that seemed foolish: they numbered over 30 documents, including the original version of the contract, WeChat correspondence records, shipping notes, receipts, and statements, one by one, and created an evidence catalog. After completing this step, the gap becomes clear - the part where the contract was modified was not confirmed with a seal, but the remaining terms, actual performance records, and proof of partial payment from the other party can form a complete performance chain.
2、 Two actions, take back the initiative
1. Apply for property preservation while filing a lawsuit
According to the relevant provisions of the Civil Code, if one party fails to perform its contractual obligations or does not perform in accordance with the agreement, it shall bear the responsibility of continuing to perform, taking remedial measures, or compensating for losses. The article itself is not complicated, the difficulty is to make the other party willing to sit down and talk.
In this case, the team applied for property preservation while suing and froze the other party's corporate account. As soon as the account was frozen, the other party's willingness to negotiate immediately changed - not because the reasoning made sense, but because the business couldn't continue. Security measures require providing guarantees, and material preparation should be done in advance. If delayed, the money in the account may be transferred.
2. Lock in jurisdiction first, don't give the other party any room to drag on
In payment disputes, the two most common methods used by the other party are raising jurisdictional objections and appealing for delayed execution after judgment. The place of contract performance in this case is in Shenzhen. Before filing the lawsuit, the team sorted out the shipping location, receiving location, reconciliation location, and invoicing information into a set of evidence, locking in the jurisdiction basis of Shenzhen Futian Court. Only when the jurisdiction level is firmly established can we talk about the pace later.
The case took four months from filing to execution, and the principal and overdue interest of the goods were collected. In addition, a penalty was also received for breach of contract. This result is not because a certain sentence is beautiful, but because the evidence catalog is detailed, the preservation application is made early, and there is no gap left in jurisdiction for the other party.
3、 Three pitfalls in the contract
1. Write the acceptance clause as "unilateral weapon"
For example, it is agreed that 'quality objections must be raised in writing within 3 days'. Some companies intentionally bypass written confirmation during the acceptance process, and when you file a lawsuit, they take out this statement saying 'you did not raise an objection within the deadline' and directly cut off the accountability path. When signing a contract, clearly state the acceptance criteria, objection deadline, and objection method. It is best to agree that "failure to raise objections within the deadline shall be deemed as acceptance qualified", which can save a lot of trouble.
2. The penalty for breach of contract should only be written as "in accordance with legal provisions"
This writing style is equivalent to not writing. Write a computable statement, such as' overdue payment shall be subject to a penalty of 0.05% per day ', with clear numbers and starting points (from the date of account confirmation or the day after the agreed payment date). Otherwise, in court, another round of' counting from which day 'will be required.
3. The subject information and account are not verified
Before signing, check three things: whether the other party's business registration information is consistent with the contract seal, whether the receiving account name is consistent with the contract subject, and whether the signatory has authorization documents. If any of these three things don't match, it could turn into 'I don't owe this money' later on.
4、 How to retain evidence? It's called 'retained'
All communication records, delivery notes, logistics receipts, and acceptance signatures must be kept in original copies. WeChat records should be exported and backed up, and emails should retain the complete sending and receiving time and email headers. I have handled a case where the other party denied receiving the goods in court. Fortunately, we kept a photo signed by the logistics driver stating that the goods had been delivered and the original receipt, which was accepted by the judge in court.
Another experience is to make regular statements. Send a monthly or quarterly statement to the other party, requesting them to stamp or have the representative sign and confirm. The role of this paper in litigation is often greater than dozens of pages of chat records.
5、 When should I move
Many bosses always feel like 'wait a little longer, don't want to go to court', waiting until the other party cancels the company, transfers assets, and can't recover a penny of the payment. In practice, it can be judged according to this rhythm: if the other party fails to make a clear repayment arrangement despite multiple reminders after the deadline, the lawyer should evaluate the evidence chain; If it is found that the other party is canceling, relocating, or disposing of assets in bulk, preservation and filing should be considered, and we cannot wait any longer. The longer the time drags on, the less property is available for execution.
Contract disputes are not about 'finding a lawyer only when there is a problem', but about 'showing a lawyer a look before signing the contract'. A company signs dozens of contracts a year, and only one or two may actually have problems, but those one or two are enough to freeze cash flow.
6、 Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What should I do if the other party says there are quality issues and refuses to pay for the goods?
Answer: First, check the acceptance criteria and objection deadline stipulated in the contract, and then check if the other party has raised a written objection within the deadline and if there is a record of inspection. If the other party only verbally says' quality is not good 'without written objections or testing reports, this defense is usually untenable. At the same time, it is necessary to keep one's own factory inspection records and the acceptance status of other customers in the same batch.
Q: Is it still worth suing if the payment has been delayed for six months?
Answer: It's worth it, but two things need to be done first: check the other party's litigation and execution situation, and determine if there are any assets available for execution; Complete the evidence chain, especially the delivery vouchers and reconciliation records. If the other party is already an "empty shell", the significance of filing a lawsuit is to fix the debt, enter the execution procedure, apply for restrictions on high consumption, and be included in the list of dishonest individuals, leaving room for future resumption of execution.
Q: Can we try sending a lawyer's letter first?
Answer: Yes, but it needs to be accompanied by evidence preparation. The function of a lawyer's letter is to fix the facts of the lawsuit, interrupt the statute of limitations, and test the other party's attitude, not a universal key. Organize the evidence before sending the letter, otherwise the other party's response with an explanation of 'unqualified quality' will only cause trouble for oneself.
Contract disputes directly affect a company's cash flow. Shenzhen experiences a significant amount of bad debts every year due to contract disputes, many of which could have been avoided during the signing phase. If you are currently owed payment or would like to review the contract terms in advance, you can chat at Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Futian District, with phone number 0755-25986969.