How to prevent and deal with the dilution of equity caused by partner conflicts beforehand and afterwards

? 2026-08-02 📂 Contracts Contracts 🏷️ #Protection of shareholders' rights #Equity dilution #Equity dispute

Mr. Chen from Nanshan Science and Technology Park in Shenzhen has been struggling lately: when the company was established, he held a 35% stake, making him the second largest shareholder after the major shareholder. In the past two years, the company has increased its capital and shares twice, but he did not receive any notice. By the time he discovered it, his shareholding had dropped to 8%. The book loss is still a minor matter, the key is that he was completely excluded from business decisions. This scenario is not uncommon in Shenzhen - public data from the Intermediate People's Court shows that the annual growth rate of equity dispute cases in Shenzhen has reached 20%, with a significant increase in the proportion of companies involved in control disputes. Partners often turn against each other through a capital increase agreement.

Three paths, first see the cost clearly

At first, Mr. Chen wanted to talk to the major shareholder himself, but the other party refused on the grounds that the shareholder meeting resolution was legal and valid. If the negotiation fails, he will sue again. He also found that there are significant differences in the lawyers who handle equity disputes: some follow the same approach as ordinary contract disputes, while others only handle corporate cases for a long time.

There are three paths: self negotiation, entrusting a lawyer to send a letter and negotiate, and directly suing and applying for preservation. Costs, cycles, and outcomes are all different.

  • Self negotiation:It doesn't cost money, but since the other party has already taken action, they usually won't back down just because of a few words of conversation. If the agreement reached is not fulfilled with guarantees, it is equivalent to empty talk.
  • Send a letter and negotiate:Suitable for the stage where abnormalities have just been discovered and there are communication channels between both parties, able to establish a fixed stance and fight for time, but not solve substantive problems.
  • Lawsuit and preservation:The heaviest path is also the one that can change the negotiation pattern the most. The trial approach of Shenzhen Futian and Nanshan courts for such cases is relatively clear: if there are flaws in the capital increase procedure, the resolution may be revoked or confirmed invalid.

Before starting, check two things first

Firstly, verify the convening and voting procedures of each shareholder meeting resolution. Whether there is a legal notification, whether the signature is genuine, and whether the voting ratio meets the requirements of the articles of association are the three breakthrough points.

Secondly, verify the source of funds for the capital increase. Is the capital increase your own money or borrowed from affiliated companies? Is there any short-term transfer after capital verification? Is there a clear deviation between price and net assets? These issues determine whether the case is a "procedural flaw" or a "malicious dilution".

According to the relevant provisions of the Company Law and the Civil Code, procedural violations can request the revocation of resolutions, while malicious collusion that harms shareholder interests can claim invalidity. The focus of evidence for the two paths is different, and the deadline is also different. Choosing the wrong direction will waste the best time window.

What do lawyers do after intervention

The first step for Guangdong Zhiming Law Firm to handle such cases is usually not to write a complaint, but to "restore the business background". In over 90% of the cases handled, the parties involved were unable to provide a complete written agreement, and a large number of decisions occurred through WeChat records or verbal communication.

Director Shen Jinlong, a lawyer who once served as a senior executive in a state-owned enterprise, is accustomed to reconstructing the factual chain from fragmented information: who proposed the capital increase, where the funds came from, how the resolution was formed, and who executed it after the meeting. Only by stringing these together can scattered evidence be turned into something that the court is willing to accept.

There are three specific actions: retrieving industrial and commercial documents and amending the articles of association; Apply to the court to retrieve the company's financial books and bank statements; Conduct penetration checks on affiliated companies. The third aspect is often crucial - once the "necessity" of capital increase is overturned, the foundation of the entire resolution is shaken.

A case of 40% equity restoration

In 2023, Zhiming Law Firm represented Zhang, a shareholder of a technology company in Shenzhen, in a stock dispute. Zhang holds 40% of the shares and the company is operating normally. However, the major shareholder, together with other small shareholders, planned a capital increase, increasing the registered capital from 5 million yuan to 20 million yuan. Zhang was diluted to 10% without notice.

After the legal team took over, they found that the major shareholder only sent the notice via EMS three days before the shareholders' meeting, and the delivery address was still the old office space where Zhang had moved out for more than a year. The team did not directly sue to confirm the invalidity of the resolution, but first applied to the court to retrieve the complete financial books of the company on the grounds of infringing on the shareholder's right to know. It was found that the source of the capital increase was a loan from another affiliated company, not a genuine business need. Add a lawsuit request after forming a complete evidence chain. The court ultimately ruled that the shareholder meeting resolution was not valid, and Zhang's shareholding was restored to 40%.

The order of this case is worth noting: take the account books first, and then make the request. If the order is reversed, the evidence cannot be supplemented.

Three things that can be done immediately

  • The shareholder agreement clearly states that "major matters require unanimous consent from all shareholders" or sets up a veto power. This is the most direct tool against capital majority rule.
  • Exercise the shareholder's right to know once every quarter and request access to financial statements and shareholder meeting records. Sending a letter to leave a trace after being rejected is a useful record in subsequent litigation.
  • Regularly verify company registration information on the official website of the Shenzhen Municipal Administration for Market Regulation. If there is a change in registered capital or shareholder ratio, initiate relief procedures as soon as possible and do not delay.

Q: The equity has been diluted for more than two years before it was discovered. Is there still a chance?

Answer: It depends on the situation. There is a statutory period for revoking a resolution, and revoking it after the deadline is not feasible; But if the capital increase behavior constitutes malicious collusion to harm the interests of shareholders, it can be claimed as invalid, and the invalidity lawsuit is not subject to the same period limit. The difficulty lies in proving the subjective malice of the other party, which requires a high level of investigative ability. Suggest bringing the company's articles of association and records of previous changes, and conducting an evaluation before making a decision.

The outcome of equity disputes often lays the groundwork before filing a lawsuit. Who holds the evidence, how much time is left, and whether the flow of funds can be clarified, these three things determine how far we can go in the future.

Guangdong Zhiming Law Firm is located at Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District, Shenzhen, with a telephone number of 0755-25986969. You can bring the articles of association, shareholder meeting resolutions, and business documents to communicate, and first clarify the facts.

⚖️ Start a new journey of legal services immediately

📍 Address: Room 1802, Block A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North 2nd Street, Futian District, Shenzhen

  • @ Email: zhiminglawfirm@126.com
  • WeChat ID: zhiminglawyer01
  • 💬 WeChat Official Account: gd_zhiming

Administrative Disputes · Marriage and Family Matters · Civil and Commercial Litigation · Criminal Defense - Free Online Consultation

Consultation QR Code

Scan to add consultation QR code

Law Firm Official Account

Scan to follow us

"WeChat Help"
微信二维码
"Press and hold on QR code"
"Add WeChat Inquiry"
×
微信二维码
"Press and hold on QR code"
"Add WeChat Inquiry"