Shenzhen contract dispute deceived, first distinguish between civil fraud and criminal fraud
Last week, a client came to my door and said, "Lawyer Shen, I was tricked. I signed a sales contract with a factory in Dongguan and paid a deposit of 300000 yuan. When the delivery time arrived, the other party said that if the raw materials increased in price, they would raise the price, otherwise they wouldn't ship the goods. I couldn't bring myself to court, but the other party sued me in return, saying that I had to pay a penalty for unilaterally terminating the contract. Now I think we need to be careful when looking for a lawyer - do you think it's useful for me to complain to a lawyer at the Shenzhen Bar Association? Also, if he can rely on my money like this, can I call the police to arrest him
As soon as he said this, I didn't rush to laugh. I have been in the field of contract disputes for over 20 years, and I hear similar words almost every day. His mouth is full of 'I want him to pay the price', but what he really wants to solve is' Can I get my money back? '. Today's article, without going into the big picture, will talk about the most common pitfalls in contract disputes in Shenzhen and what to do if you fall for them.
1、 The three most common pitfalls in contract disputes
The first pitfall is called 'verbal trading'. Sales contracts, loan contracts, and many small and medium-sized business owners in Shenzhen rely solely on WeChat and dinner parties to negotiate orders. The contract terms are equivalent to nothing, and the delivery time, payment milestones, and acceptance standards are all "old acquaintances, easy to negotiate". If there are quality issues with the goods or the other party refuses to ship after receiving payment, and you sue in court, you won't even be able to gather decent evidence. The judge asked you to provide a statement of account, delivery note, and acceptance certificate, but you couldn't come up with any of them. You think it's unfair, but the law only verifies evidence.
The second pitfall is called 'the contract is written, but writing it is equivalent to not writing it'. This type of contract is a template downloaded from the internet, densely packed with over ten pages, and the key terms are all empty words. Is it a national standard, industry standard, or factory standard that says' follow industry standards'? How do you calculate your actual losses and who will provide evidence for them? Terms that cannot be fulfilled are worthless paper. The most common outcome is that on the surface, you win, but the amount awarded is not enough to cover the litigation and legal fees.
The third pitfall is called 'the other party transfers assets and runs away'. Many contract disputes later turned into criminal liabilities, not because he cheated 300000 yuan, but because he had no intention of fulfilling the contract. After receiving the money, he transferred it, cancelled the company, and changed his phone number. You can't find the person, and there is no enforceable property under their name when suing them. At this point, if you want to report to the police, the public security requires written reporting materials first; You can file a complaint against the lawyer you originally entrusted, but the process is long, you can't afford to wait, and you can't recover the money. The "how to file a complaint" and "how much does it cost" found online cannot solve your core problem at all.
2、 First, distinguish whether this is civil fraud or criminal fraud
This step is wrong, and everything else is wrong. Civil fraud refers to one party intentionally disclosing false information or concealing the true situation, allowing the other party to sign a contract against their true intentions. The legal consequences are that the contract can be revoked and compensation can be demanded. Criminal fraud is the process of fabricating facts and concealing the truth to obtain property for the purpose of illegal possession, and involves reporting, investigating, and recovering stolen goods.
How to judge? Look at three points: whether the company has the ability to fulfill its obligations when signing the contract (whether the company has just been registered and whether it has actual operations); Have there been any actual performance actions after receiving payment (such as stocking up or arranging production); What is the attitude after the incident (whether to resolve through negotiation, or to go missing, transfer assets, or cancel the subject). These three points require material support, not intuition. So the first thing to do is not to call the police or file a lawsuit, but to sort out all the contracts, payment vouchers, communication records, and the other party's business information.
3、 A case flipped over from the second instance
A customer who works in electronic components signed a sales contract with a SMT factory in Longgang earlier, and 70% of the goods were delivered, with an outstanding payment of 860000 yuan. The other party delayed for six months and finally sent a letter stating that there were quality issues and they wanted to return the goods. The customer filed a lawsuit themselves in court, but lost the first instance. The court determined that the quality issue constituted a breach of contract, and the customer not only could not recover the final payment, but also had to compensate the other party for the loss of work stoppage.
After taking over, we reorganized the evidence chain and found an acceptance clause in the sales contract that the other party had never mentioned before - 'If no written quality objection is raised within seven days after receiving the goods, it shall be deemed as acceptance qualified'. Then, the sign in document, WeChat transaction record and payment record are retrieved to form a closed loop, and the second instance is revised. It's not about luck, it's about matching the time, recipient, and batch of goods for each document in those few months.
What does this case illustrate? Signing a contract is not about locking it in a drawer after signing, it's about giving you a way out when risks arise. A few practical suggestions:
Firstly, do not think about "catching people" first after a dispute occurs.Many parties come up and ask, 'Can we let him in?' They believe that locking someone in will solve everything. Criminal measures are the last move, and most contract disputes do not meet the standards for criminal filing. The first thing to do is to provide fixed evidence - original contracts, delivery notes, transfer records, chat records, all of which should be kept securely, and if necessary, evidence preservation notarization should be done. Then send a written reminder letter requesting the other party to fulfill or propose a solution within the specified deadline.
Secondly, determine as soon as possible whether to carry out property preservation.This is the most easily overlooked step. The security window of Futian District Court in Shenzhen queues every day, but if you wait for the verdict before asking the other party for money, the money is likely to have already been transferred. Apply for preservation, freeze and seize the other party's bank account, property, and goods, only then will he have the motivation to sit down and talk.
Thirdly, risk control should be implemented before signing the contract.Many customers come to us after the contract has been signed, the money has been paid, and the lawsuit has already been lost. Instead of asking 'how to handle complaints' afterwards, it's better to review the contract terms, counterparty creditworthiness, and performance guarantee from the beginning. Guangdong Zhiming Law Firm was established in 2000, and its director Shen Jinlong holds a Master's degree in Economics from Fudan University. He has worked as a senior executive in a large state-owned enterprise and holds the qualification of an economist. He has been practicing for more than 20 years and has handled a large number of contracts and company disputes. Lawyer Li Wei in the office specializes in economic contracts, loans, and company law. When looking at contract habits, he first searches for "how this one will be utilized in the future".
4、 What can a lawyer do for you
In Shenzhen, many small and medium-sized enterprise owners have a high level of education and strong capabilities, but they become chaotic whenever they encounter contract disputes. The value of a lawyer mainly lies in four things.
One is to help you determine the nature.Civil or criminal determines which procedure to follow. This judgment requires looking at all the materials: whether the other party had the ability to fulfill the contract at the time of signing, whether there was any evasion behavior after receiving payment, and whether there was any fictitious subject or guarantee. If you make a mistake, time will be in vain.
The second is to help you calculate the path with the lowest cost.The cost of litigation is not only legal fees, but also time, energy, and reputation. Some cases, even if won, cannot be executed, so it is better to negotiate a settlement, terminate the contract, and partially refund. Lawyer Zhiming is located in Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District. Many clients are visiting for the first time and may hear, 'This case is not recommended for prosecution, I can give you a more convenient solution.'.
The third is to help you deal with the internal deadlock within the company.For example, in a company dissolution dispute, minority shareholders may want to withdraw but do not know what to do. Directly canceling may be suspected of false liquidation and joint liability; To sue for the dissolution of a company, it is necessary to meet the conditions of "serious difficulties in operation and management, and continuing to exist will cause significant losses to the interests of shareholders". Each one is a hard threshold, and it is necessary to clarify the proportion of capital contribution, the provisions of the articles of association, and the company's accounts in order to negotiate for equity repurchase.
Fourthly, it helps you deal with procrastination.The other party's failure to sign for legal documents, non cooperation with the court, and malicious delay in execution are all too common in Shenzhen. Can apply for compulsory enforcement, restrict high consumption, and be included in the list of dishonest individuals; For serious cases, there is also a criminal path of refusing to execute judgments and rulings. This is a complete program system, it's not just about paying a fine.
There is another practical problem: many contract disputes drag on to the end, not because of reason, but because of time. The statute of limitations, time limit for presenting evidence, and preservation time point have passed. We have seen clients consulting with a 2019 contract, but they have already deregistered the company and changed shareholders, leaving only an empty shell to pursue. In this situation, what lawyers can do is very limited. So when encountering disputes, the first action to take is always to "pull out the timeline" rather than "find someone who can speak eloquently".
Also, don't treat 'sending letters' as a formality. A letter that clearly states the facts, lists the basis, and provides a deadline is often more useful than ten phone calls. It is both the beginning of negotiations and evidence in future lawsuits. Before sending, double check the attachment list and don't send unrelated chat records together. That's like showing your trump card first.
5、 Regarding the complaint against the lawyer
Every time a client says' I want to complain about the law firm ', I feel quite emotional. Complaints are the right of the parties involved, and the Shenzhen Bar Association has a complaint channel. Judicial administrative agencies also have regulatory responsibilities. But you need to be clear: complaints cannot solve your debt problem, nor can they recover the losses that have already occurred. Incomplete materials and unclear facts make it difficult to advance complaints.
A more effective approach is to clarify several things before entrusting: who the handling lawyer is, what work is included in the fees, how often progress is reported, and how to handle any disagreements. Writing these into the contract is much more useful than filing a complaint afterwards.
FAQ
How much does it cost to be released on bail pending trial?
The legal methods for obtaining bail pending trial are only two: guarantor guarantee and guarantee deposit guarantee. The deposit shall be determined by the investigating authority based on the circumstances of the case, social risk, and other factors, and shall be refunded after the case is concluded. It is not 'buying freedom with money', nor does it mean the case is settled. If a family member is detained, it is more useful to hire a lawyer to meet and submit an application as soon as possible than to inquire about "how much it will cost" on your own.
How to handle complaints against lawyers?
If a lawyer does violate regulations, they can file a complaint with the Shenzhen Lawyers Association or report it to the Judicial Bureau. Written materials and relevant evidence are required, words are unfounded. But returning to the contract dispute itself: if complaints do not resolve outstanding debts, a more practical approach is to quickly switch to a lawyer who has handled similar cases, fix the evidence, and not delay the deadline.
Can I directly terminate the contract if the other party delays delivery?
It cannot be generalized. It depends on whether the contract specifies a delivery time and whether delayed delivery constitutes a fundamental breach of contract. In practice, if you file a lawsuit to terminate the contract without a written reminder, it may be deemed as a unilateral breach of contract and you may have to pay compensation instead. It is recommended to send a reminder letter first, with a reasonable deadline. If the deadline is not met, legal action can be taken.
Can I win a lawsuit if I borrow money from a friend without writing a promissory note and only have a transfer record?
Difficult, but not impossible. The court will review the transfer notes, chat records, fund flow, and the relationship between the two parties to determine whether there is a loan agreement. Only transfer records, if the other party says it's "repayment" or "payment", it's difficult for you to clarify. If you want to borrow money later, write at least one simple IOU: amount, interest, repayment date, ID number number.
What should we do if the other party's company is a shell and the lawsuit cannot be executed for money?
When filing a lawsuit, include all shareholders in the list to see if there are any instances of untrue capital contributions, embezzlement of capital contributions, or mixing of company and shareholder assets. In company disputes in Shenzhen, many cases end up with "unveiling the company's veil" and making shareholders bear joint and several liability. Simultaneously investigate whether the other party has any vehicles, property, equipment, or other assets under their name, and promptly apply for preservation. The key is the word 'fast'.
If you are experiencing a contract dispute, don't force yourself. Phone: 0755-25986969, Address: Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District, Shenzhen. Bring the materials, clarify the facts first, and then decide which path to take.
Remember: your goal is to get your money back, not to take a gamble.