Shenzhen private trust redemption default, what steps should investors take to protect their rights
At the end of last year, an investor living in Futian, Shenzhen approached us: he invested in a private equity fund with a principal of 7.4 million yuan and a contract stating a three-year lock up period. After expiration, the net asset value dropped to 0.3%, and the manager not only refused to pay dividends, but also refused to repay the principal. He was so anxious that he couldn't sleep all night - 'Isn't this a market risk? Can we still get the money back?' This was his third time looking for a lawyer, and the first two responses he received were: 'I signed the private equity contract and accepted it, it's difficult to type.'.
1、 What are the differences between the three paths in front of him
There are over 30000 financial cases in Shenzhen each year, including financing leases, trust defaults, bank loans, and private fund repayments, each with its own unique approach. The same 'money cannot be retrieved', the approach to handling it is completely different.
Find your own institutional theoryVery few can get their money back. The language of managers has been practiced, and a single sentence of 'bear the market risk' can block you, not to mention the fact that contracts often state 'not guaranteed capital, not guaranteed returns'.
Send a lawyer's letter to exert pressureIt is useful for institutions that are still operating and want to continue fundraising, as it can force them to return to the negotiating table; But if the other party's account is already out of money, the effectiveness of the letter is limited.
Directly sue or arbitrateIt is a means of sealing accounts and freezing assets, but financial cases have a long trial cycle, a large amount of evidence preparation work, and high requirements for lawyers.
The choice of path depends on a core judgment: whether the other party still has the ability to repay. A lawyer's letter can have a shocking effect on those who have assets and still want to continue working; For those who have already fled or are insolvent, only by filing a lawsuit and property preservation can they get the money ahead of others.
Q: Can these three methods be used simultaneously? Answer: Yes, the order is specific. The common practice is to first use a lawyer's letter to probe, giving a seven to fifteen day observation period. Once the other party responds vaguely or procrastinates, property preservation and filing will be immediately initiated, without giving the other party time to transfer assets.
2、 Under what circumstances is it recommended to file a lawsuit directly
If the target amount is relatively large and words such as "expected returns" and "guaranteed repurchase" appear in the contract, it is generally recommended to enter into litigation or arbitration as soon as possible and apply for property preservation. The provisions of the Civil Code on contract termination are very clear: if one party delays the performance of its obligations or commits other breaches, resulting in the inability to achieve the purpose of the contract, the other party may terminate the contract and request compensation for losses. The manager's failure to make timely payments is a typical breach of contract.
In recent years, the division of labor in Shenzhen courts for financial cases has been relatively detailed, but judges still focus on the evidence chain: contracts, fundraising prospectuses, risk assessment questionnaires, position disclosures, fund flows, and communication records. Whoever has all the materials has weight.
3、 Same lawsuit, different entry points
Some lawyers only perform according to the contract, but the breakthrough in financial cases often lies outside the contract. Lawyer Zhiming has been working in Shenzhen for over 20 years and has represented many such disputes. Director Shen Jinlong holds a Master's degree and is an economist from Fudan University. He has been practicing for over 20 years and has worked as a senior executive in state-owned enterprises. When they look at such cases, they usually ask three questions first: Has the manager disclosed their holdings as agreed? Is the stop loss line just a formality? Is there a risk assessment conducted when selling products?
These three questions, when examined in detail, actually all point to the same thing - the obligation to sell appropriateness. The "Nine Minutes of the People's Republic of China" clearly states the obligation of appropriateness: if the selling institution fails to fulfill its obligations such as disclosure and risk assessment, resulting in losses to investors, it shall bear corresponding compensation responsibilities. Many cases have been pushed to the back, and the dispute is over these few pieces of paper.
Q: I am not a local of Shenzhen, can I entrust it? Answer: Yes. The jurisdiction of financial disputes is relatively flexible, and both the place of contract performance and the defendant's domicile can be registered. Out of town clients can be entrusted remotely, materials can be sent by express delivery, communication can be done via video, and court hearings can be attended by lawyers.
4、 A case that can be dismantled
Lawyer Zhiming once represented a private equity fund dispute in Shenzhen. The client invested 7.4 million yuan, but after the deadline, the manager evaded it for nine months with the excuse of "project suspension". Later, he simply did not answer the phone. After taking over, two breakthroughs were identified: firstly, this product has not undergone risk assessment for investors, and its suitability obligations have not been fully fulfilled; Secondly, the investment target stated in the contract does not match the actual flow of funds, and the money has been deposited into the accounts of affiliated companies.
The lawyer simultaneously applied for property preservation and froze the other party's two bank accounts. The other party actively applied for mediation after the account was frozen, and the customer retrieved the principal and corresponding interest. This result is not because of any fancy words, but because the evidence chain has fixed the fact that the manager did not follow the agreement.
5、 Three practical suggestions
1、 All contracts, transfer vouchers, chat records, product promotion materials, and risk assessment questionnaires have been collected. Missing any one item may lead the other party to find reasons for procrastination. 2、 Don't miss the moment of property preservation. When the other party's company is still operating and the account is still running, they need to apply. The online filing and online preservation of the Shenzhen court are relatively mature, and if all the materials are complete, the ruling will be made quickly. 3、 When unsure, it is more useful to first consult a lawyer to review the materials before taking action, rather than searching online for half a month on your own.
It should be noted that the outcome of a financial dispute depends on the contractual agreement, evidence, and the other party's ability to pay, and no lawyer can promise to recover a certain amount. What can be done is to get the program right, step on the right timing, and control executable assets first.
Consultation hotline: 0755-25986969; Address: Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District, Shenzhen.