The rules and practical points of electronic evidence in civil litigation
In civil litigation, electronic evidence has become a key type of evidence, covering emails, WeChat chat records, electronic contracts, system logs, and more. According to the Civil Procedure Law and relevant judicial interpretations, electronic data needs to meet the requirements of authenticity, legality, and relevance in order to serve as the basis for determining cases.
The authenticity check is whether the generation, storage, and transmission process of electronic data is complete and whether there are any traces of tampering. In practice, the parties involved should submit the original carrier (mobile phone, computer, server) and ensure that the data has not been deleted or modified. Legitimacy emphasizes that evidence collection methods must not violate legal prohibitions, such as unauthorized access to other people's accounts to obtain chat records, which may be excluded. Relevance requires electronic evidence to be directly related to the facts of the case, such as electronic signatures in contract disputes that can correspond to the signing parties.
Rules of Evidence and Submission Process
In terms of submission format, electronic evidence is usually submitted in the form of printed copies, CDs, or mobile storage media, accompanied by a source description that clearly states the time, method, and storage location of evidence collection. The court generally requires the provision of raw data: WeChat records should display a complete dialogue interface, including timestamps and sender information, and cannot only extract a few sentences that are advantageous to oneself; Email should retain the complete email header; Electronic contracts require verification of signature validity through a certification platform.
In practical operation, it is common practice to do notarization or trustworthy timestamp in advance, which can reduce the space for the other party to question the authenticity. For electronic contracts stored in the cloud, a certification report or verification result issued by the platform must be submitted together. In addition, electronic evidence must be submitted within the time limit for presenting evidence, and may not be accepted after the deadline; If there are indeed difficulties, an extension should be applied for in a timely manner.
Practical points and risk prevention
There are three key points: firstly, fix it in a timely manner, save it through screenshot, screen recording, export and other methods, and make remote backups to prevent device loss or data cleaning; Secondly, when applying for court access, it is necessary to specify the server location, storage subject, and data scope. The more specific the request, the smoother the access will be; Thirdly, when the other party questions the integrity, they can apply for judicial appraisal, and the appraisal institution will make a judgment on the integrity and formation time of the data.
In terms of risk prevention, it is important to note that electronic evidence can be easily deleted or covered. It is recommended to preserve it at the beginning of a dispute, rather than waiting until before filing a lawsuit. At the same time, avoid using illegal software to obtain data, and do not modify or concatenate chat records without authorization, otherwise you may bear adverse consequences.
Another point that is often overlooked is that the probative value of electronic evidence often depends on whether it can be corroborated with other evidence. The combination of chat records, transfer records, shipping orders, and acceptance records forms a closed loop, which is much more powerful than a single chat record.