When a Partner Turns Hostile and a Capital Increase Dilutes Equity from 40% Down to 8%, Can You Fight for Your Rights? A Shenzhen Lawyer Explains Shareholder Rights Protection in 4 Questions and 4 Answers
Zhang (pseudonym), who runs a SaaS company in Nanshan, Shenzhen, has been suffering from severe insomnia lately. When he started the business, he contributed the technology and built the team, holding 40% equity. Last year, his partner said they wanted to bring in a new investor, and Zhang signed off on it. A year later, when he reviewed the business registration records, he discovered his equity had been diluted to just 8% — the new investor took 50%, and the partner even gave themselves an extra 10%. He came to us in Futian and asked outright: "I have no objection to a capital increase and share expansion, but if they play it this way, can I still get my equity back?"
It is unlawful. A company's capital increase and share expansion must be voted on by the shareholders' meeting; it cannot take effect merely because the founder signs privately. Article 34 of the Company Law clearly provides: when a company increases its registered capital, shareholders have the right to subscribe for the newly increased capital on a priority basis in proportion to their paid-in capital contributions. In practice, many investors do not directly increase capital, but instead use three methods to set up schemes: establishing a limited partnership shareholding platform, increasing capital at a low price, and inflating the valuation of intangible assets. Equity dispute cases in Shenzhen have grown by an average of 20% per year, with claims of infringement of shareholders' rights on the grounds of "dilution through capital increase" accounting for nearly one-third of them. However, the prerequisite is that you must act within the statutory period—according to Article 22 of the Company Law, if the content of a shareholders' resolution violates laws or the articles of association, a shareholder may request the people's court to revoke it within 60 days from the date the resolution is made. After 60 days, you lose this right.
Yes, but it depends on the evidence. Last year, Zhiming Law Firm handled a similar case in Futian, Shenzhen: a technology company had three shareholders, and the major shareholder wanted to exclude two founders. They designed a "targeted capital increase" and issued additional shares to their controlled holding platform at a valuation of 1 yuan per share, diluting the other two shareholders from 40% and 30% to 10% and 8%. After accepting the case, we did not directly file a "revocation lawsuit", but took two paths: on the one hand, we applied for access to the industrial and commercial archives and reviewed the minutes of the shareholders' meeting, and fixed the evidence of illegal procedures; The other side filed a lawsuit with the court to confirm that the capital increase resolution is not valid. In the end, the court adopted our agency opinion on "malicious collusion to harm the legitimate rights and interests of others", ruled that the capital increase resolution was invalid, and restored the equity ratio of the two shareholders to its original state. When Director Lawyer Shen Jinlong led the team to handle this case, they used this set of case handling methods - not focusing on a single claim basis, but combining the resolution effectiveness, shareholder's right to know, and infringement liability in the company law to jointly promote, ultimately helping the parties to protect a total of 40% of their equity. This case lasted for 9 months and went through a three-level process, which was difficult, but if the direction was right, it could be overturned.
This is another form of infringement independent of equity dilution. The shareholder's right to information is a fundamental right, and the law has your back. Article 33 of the Company Law stipulates that shareholders have the right to inspect and copy the company's articles of association, minutes of shareholders' meetings, resolutions of the board of directors, resolutions of the board of supervisors, and financial accounting reports; as for accounting books, a written request must be made with the purpose stated. If the company fails to respond within 15 days or refuses, you have the right to file a lawsuit. Among the equity disputes involving enterprises in Longhua District handled by Zhiming Law Firm, more than 60% of the parties simultaneously asserted claims for "right to information + profit distribution." However, note that in recent years, Shenzhen courts have rendered different rulings on whether a shareholder's inspection of accounting vouchers includes original vouchers. Before filing the case, it is best to have a lawyer review the wording of your claims for you first, so as to avoid winning the right to information but failing to obtain the actual books.
Your sense of smell is better than most people's. A large number of shareholder disputes do not erupt in an instant, but gradually dilute through three or five small capital increases. By the time you realize it, the 60 day revocation period has often passed. The three most practical ways to lock up rights in advance are: firstly, to stipulate in the company's articles of association that "capital increase requires unanimous consent from all shareholders", upgrading the default rule in Article 34 of the Company Law to a special agreement; Secondly, sign a concerted action agreement to clarify the binding of voting rights and prevent the other party from wooing third parties; Thirdly, agree on anti dilution clauses - such as "in the event of subsequent financing dilution, the founder has the right to subscribe to the newly added registered capital at the original price" or "if the company increases capital below its net asset value, it shall be deemed as compensation from the major shareholder for the loss of shareholder interests". Guangdong Zhiming Law Firm has been deeply rooted in Shenzhen for 26 years, and has represented a large number of cases, witnessing the process of a large number of shareholders from being intimate to going to court. Director Shen Jinlong, a lawyer, often says that an agreement is a stop loss order written before the conflict. If we wait for the partners to turn their backs before discussing, we will either spend a lot of money or put in a lot of effort.
In equity matters, the most expensive thing isn't the lawyer's fee—it's that feeling of swallowing your pride yet being powerless to turn things around. If you're facing the predicament of equity dilution, being sidelined, or forced out of the company, or even if you just have a vague sense that there's a "hidden trap" in your articles of association or agreements, call 0755-25986969 and talk to Zhiming Law Firm. A phone call isn't expensive. Once you get your questions answered, half of your peace of mind is restored.
Need professional legal help?
📞 Free consultation: 0755-25986969 (weekdays 9:00-18:00)
📍 Address: Room 1802, Tower A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North 2nd Street, Futian District, Shenzhen
⚡ First phone consultation free