If the other party does not agree to a divorce, how long will a lawsuit in Futian, Shenzhen take? In one case I handled, the case was concluded through mediation in three months.
Last November, when Ms. Zhang from Futian came to me, she was clutching a three-page divorce agreement that the other party had thrown into the trash without even looking at it. "He said he would drag it out until I gave up—that as long as he refused to sign, the divorce could never happen." Ms. Zhang's voice was calm as she said this, but her fingers kept trembling. She and her husband had been married for 12 years, owned a home in Nanshan worth about 9 million yuan, and had a 9-year-old child. Their relationship had broken down and they had been separated for nearly two years, yet the husband still refused to agree to a divorce and would not discuss either property or custody. What she feared most was not losing out on money—it was not being able to afford the time.
很多人以为对方不签字就离不了,这是个误区。协议离婚确实需要双方到场、自愿签署,但只要一方不同意,另一方可直接向法院起诉。张女士这种情况,走诉讼离婚是唯一出路。问题在于,诉讼离婚到底要多久?财产和抚养权怎么争?
先说时间。深圳每年离婚登记约5万对,诉讼离婚占比不低,福田、南山法院的家事案件排期一直比较紧。一般简易程序审限3个月,普通程序6个月,但实际耗时往往更长——如果涉及房产评估、对方故意拖延、管辖权异议,拖到一年以上也不少见。张女士的案子我们3个月就调解结案了,这里面有策略,也有运气。
关键在哪?《民法典》第1079条规定,法院审理离婚案件应当先调解;感情确已破裂、调解无效的,应当准予离婚。这条是诉讼离婚的核心依据。但”感情破裂”怎么证明,直接决定案子走向。张女士分居近两年,有租房合同、水电缴费记录、微信聊天记录佐证,加上男方在调解中承认”过不下去”,感情破裂这一关基本没争议。
真正的硬仗是财产和抚养权。深圳离婚诉讼中70%涉及房产分割,争议标的平均300万到800万。张女士那套南山房产是婚后购买,登记在双方名下,属于夫妻共同财产。但男方主张首付中有200万是他父母出的,要求多分。我们调取了当年的转账记录,发现这笔钱是从男方父亲账户直接转入开发商账户,没有借条,也没有明确赠与一方的意思表示。按《民法典》第1062条,婚后受赠财产原则上属于共同财产,除非赠与合同明确只归一方。这一点,我们提前做了证据固定。
抚养权方面,孩子9岁,法院会考虑孩子意愿、双方抚养能力、生活环境稳定性。张女士是深户,在福田有稳定工作,孩子一直在福田上学。男方虽然收入更高,但常年出差,实际陪伴时间少。我们提交了张女士的工资流水、学校证明、社区居住证明,以及孩子亲笔写的”想跟妈妈生活”的说明。这些材料在调解阶段就摆出来,对方律师看完,态度明显松动。
代理策略上,我们没有一上来就猛攻,而是分三步走。第一步,立案同时申请财产保全,防止男方转移存款和股票。第二步,主动申请调解,把房产分割方案和抚养权安排做成两套备选,给对方留出谈判空间。第三步,抓住男方”不想上法庭、怕影响公司股权”的心理,在调解中适度施压。说白了,打官司不是目的,拿到结果才是。
最后的结果是调解结案:房产归张女士,她补偿男方280万,分两年付清;孩子由张女士抚养,男方每月支付抚养费6000元,享有探视权。从立案到拿到调解书,整整3个月。张女士后来跟我说,她原本做好了打两年官司的准备,没想到这么快。
问:对方不同意离婚,第一次起诉法院会判离吗?
答:不一定。如果对方坚决不同意,且没有家暴、分居满两年等法定情形,第一次起诉有可能判不离。但6个月后可以再次起诉,第二次判离概率会明显提高。关键是第一次就要把感情破裂的证据做扎实。
同类案子我经手不少,有几点提醒。一是别等,分居时间、财产线索、对方收入变化,越早固定越好。二是别贪,财产分割和抚养权有时候需要取舍,全都要往往拖更久。三是别自己谈,对方不同意离婚的情况下,谈判基本无效,反而容易暴露底牌。深圳福田、南山、龙华的法院家事审判风格有差异,选对策略比选对法院更重要。
如果你也遇到对方拖着不签字、财产说不清、孩子抚养权谈不拢的情况,建议尽早找专业婚姻家事律师评估。广东知明律师事务所扎根深圳26年,累计代理案件超10000+件,婚姻家事团队在福田、南山、龙华都有实操经验。沈金龙主任律师有26年执业经历,复旦大学硕士、高级经济师,对房产分割和股权类财产处理有专门研究。有需要可以打电话聊聊:0755-25986969,地址在深圳市福田区石厦北二街新天世纪商务中心A座1802室。
Regarding the cases mentioned in the article, if you have similar situations as well.
You can directly call 0755-25986969 to talk to a marriage and family lawyer. The first consultation is free. The law firm is located at Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District, Shenzhen.