Shenzhen buying house transfer stuck, one house sold twice, where should we take our rights protection

📅 2026-08-15 📂 Legal News Legal News 🏷️ #Dual Sale of Property Rights Protection #Confirmation of property rights for small property-right houses #Shenzhen Property Dispute

Two days ago afternoon, Mr. Liu, who runs a small business in Longhua, Shenzhen, came to me. He bought a second-hand house in Bao'an in 2023, with a total price of 6.8 million yuan and a deposit of 800000 yuan. However, the original owner refused to cooperate with the transfer for nine months and quietly mortgaged the house to the bank for a loan of 3 million yuan. Mr. Liu was so angry that he couldn't sleep all night: 'I paid for the house in my name, what should I do?' This is not an isolated case. The real estate disputes in Shenzhen involve large amounts of money and complex legal relationships. Today, without using jargon, we will explain high-frequency issues such as stuck property transfers, two house sales, and disputes over small property rights in the order of "looking at the door and grasping the key".

深圳房产纠纷

1、 Why do some people get their money back while others can't, even though it's a property dispute

On the surface, both parties have signed contracts and paid for the property, but the watershed lies in three points: whether the contract terms cover breach of contract liability, whether the evidence chain is complete, and whether actions have been taken within the statute of limitations. The provisions of the Civil Code on changes in real estate rights are very clear, and registration shall prevail. Without transfer of ownership, the house does not belong to you legally. Many parties think that holding the contract means stability, but in fact, it is only a debt certificate, not a property certificate. So the first thing the lawyer does after taking over is to determine whether the existing evidence can support the two paths of "continuing to perform" or "terminating the refund and compensation".

2、 How to choose between self negotiation, sending a lawyer's letter, or filing a lawsuit directly

Talk about it yourself.Suitable for cases where the seller only wants to increase the price and the emotional confrontation is not serious. The disadvantage is the lack of legal pressure, and it is common to delay for six months without results. It is also easy to miss the window of property preservation.Send a lawyer's letter.Low cost and fast speed, the function is to interrupt the statute of limitations of litigation, fix the fact of the other party's breach of contract, and at the same time give the other party some pressure, suitable for disputes with small subject matter, houses, and relocation space.Directly file a lawsuit.Suitable for situations where the other party has already transferred the property, taken a second mortgage, or gone missing, sue and apply for property preservation, freeze the involved property, and prevent the house from being disposed of for the third time.

There is no absolute superiority or inferiority among the three options, the key lies in the strength of the evidence and the other party's ability to fulfill the contract. One thing to remind: if the other party has already mortgaged the house to the bank, the bank may be a third party acting in good faith. If you request to continue the transfer, you will encounter obstacles. At this time, "terminating the contract and claiming compensation" is often more realistic than "forcing the house".

3、 Can we still get the house back if we sell it twice

Q: The seller has already transferred the property to a third party, can I still retrieve it?
Answer: It depends on whether the third party constitutes a good faith acquisition. If a third party has paid reasonable consideration, completed registration, and is unaware of the previous transaction, you are likely to not be able to retrieve the house. However, according to the provisions of the Civil Code on breach of contract liability, you can demand the return of the paid house price and compensation for the losses caused by the increase in house price. If a third party colludes maliciously with the seller, such as relatives transferring ownership at a low price or knowingly taking over the property even after it has been sold, according to the provisions of the Civil Code on invalid civil legal acts, the contract may be deemed invalid, and you still have a chance to recover the property.

The key to this type of case lies in evidence collection: the signing time of two contracts, payment vouchers, online signing records, communication records of intermediaries, and the relative relationship between the other party and a third party, all of which are materials for determining whether they are "good faith" or "collusion".

4、 Is it true that there is no space for property rights confirmation in small property rights houses

Q: Is it completely impossible for small property rights houses in Shenzhen?
Answer: Depending on the situation. The court may support the confirmation of rights in the transfer of homesteads and houses among villagers in this village; For small property rights houses purchased by non villagers, most of the sales contracts are deemed invalid, but the buyer can claim that the seller bears the responsibility for breach of contract, demand the return of the purchase price, and compensate for actual losses such as decoration and relocation. Some historical legacy buildings in Shenzhen have been declared and can be converted to permanent status if they meet the conditions. There are significant differences in individual cases, so let the lawyer review the information before drawing a conclusion. Don't give up on your own first.

Another type that is often overlooked is cooperative housing construction. From the 1990s to the beginning of this century, there were many cases in Shenzhen where village joint-stock companies cooperated with developers to build houses. The houses were sold, but the certificates were never obtained. The breakthrough point for such cases lies not in whether the sales contract is valid, but in whether the historical cooperative construction behavior is established and whether the mortgage registration is legal. The train of thought has changed, and the path has emerged.

5、 A case that took fourteen months to complete

In 2022, a village stock company in Nanshan District cooperated with a developer to build a 3800 square meter factory land. Thirty two homeowners paid in full and lived in it for six years, but the developer delayed obtaining the certificate and even packaged some of the houses for mortgage financing. After being represented by a lawyer, the illegal mortgage registration was first revoked through administrative litigation, and then the basis was established through a lawsuit to confirm the validity of the contract. Finally, 32 homeowners were helped to complete the property rights confirmation, with a total valuation of over 100 million yuan. The core breakthrough point of this case is to transform the dilemma of "the buyer has no right to confirm the property rights" into an argument that "historical cooperative building behavior is effective" - without long-term experience in real estate cases, the first administrative review cannot pass.

Add another sentence about the lawsuit request. When filing a property dispute lawsuit, how to write the request directly determines whether it can be executed later. The preparation of evidence, preservation of objects, and trial period for the two paths of obtaining the house (continuing to fulfill obligations, assisting in transfer) or asking for money (terminating the contract, returning the house payment, compensating for losses) are different. Some people write both, and the court will require clarification; Some people only write about asking for money and only realize their losses when housing prices rise. This choice should be made before filing a lawsuit, and cannot be changed at the same time.

6、 Three anti pitfalls actions for Shenzhen homebuyers

Whether you're buying a home in Futian or Longgang, keep these points in mind.Firstly, make a pre registration immediately after online signing.The provisions of the Civil Code on advance notice registration specify that if the immovable property is disposed of without the consent of the right holder after advance notice registration, it shall not have biological rights effect. This step doesn't cost much, but it can directly cut off the possibility of the seller's secondary mortgage and resale.Secondly, the search cannot be done only once.Before signing, print the real estate registration information, and check again three days before the property transfer. Any newly added mortgage in between could be a sign of an impending blowup.Thirdly, keep all payment vouchers and communication records.In WeChat, the other party said 'the house won't be sold for now' and 'I'll borrow some money to redeem the building', which are all supporting evidence to restore the truth in court.

The biggest fear of property disputes is not trouble, but delaying opportunities. If the house is gone, you can buy it again. If the money is tied up and the deadline has passed, it will be difficult to turn the tables again. If you are stuck in transfer of ownership, one bedroom two sales, or small property rights issues and unsure of what to do next, you can call 0755-25986969 or have a face-to-face conversation at Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District, Shenzhen. Bringing contracts, payment vouchers, and search records is more effective than thinking a hundred times at home.

⚖️ Start a new journey of legal services immediately

📍 Address: Room 1802, Block A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North 2nd Street, Futian District, Shenzhen

  • @ Email: zhiminglawfirm@126.com
  • WeChat ID: zhiminglawyer01
  • 💬 WeChat Official Account: gd_zhiming

Administrative Disputes · Marriage and Family Matters · Civil and Commercial Litigation · Criminal Defense - Free Online Consultation

Consultation QR Code

Scan to add consultation QR code

Law Firm Official Account

Scan to follow us

"WeChat Help"
微信二维码
"Press and hold on QR code"
"Add WeChat Inquiry"
×
微信二维码
"Press and hold on QR code"
"Add WeChat Inquiry"