How to choose a lawyer when filing a lawsuit in Shenzhen? First, avoid three misconceptions
Many friends often ask: How to choose a lawyer when filing a lawsuit in Shenzhen? Can you believe those chest slapping words online? To be honest, this question is more difficult to answer than many legal questions themselves. As a media observer who frequently visits Shenzhen's legal department, I have seen many clients enter law firms with promises of "no problem with the outcome," but in the end, the cases are not handled satisfactorily; I have also seen some teams that are not very good at advertising, taking seemingly hopeless cases step by step. Today, let's take Guangdong Zhiming Law Firm as a sample to talk about the pitfalls to avoid when hiring a lawyer in a city like Shenzhen, which has a relatively advanced judicial practice.
1、 The current situation of the legal service market in Shenzhen: why can't we trust promises
The number of lawyers in Shenzhen has exceeded 20000, with over a thousand law firms. The market is thriving and competition is fierce. Open your phone and the screen will be filled with notifications such as' guaranteed results' and 'team combat'. But the truth is:Talking about the outcome without considering the specific case itself is not valid.
Recently, a friend came to me with a property inheritance document. He talked to several law firms before and after, and one of them said that the case was' not a big problem '. I have reviewed the materials, which include the welfare housing allocation policy for early housing reform, the validity of the will of the deceased spouse, and the substitutionary inheritance relationship between heirs. Even lawyers who have handled inheritance disputes for many years can only say 'can fight' for such cases and will not give a conclusion. Why?The outcome of a difficult case depends on whether the evidence chain is complete, how the judge determines the facts, and how the other party provides evidence and cross examination. None of these factors can be unilaterally decided by a lawyer.
The judicial standards of Shenzhen courts have been renowned for their meticulous handling and keeping up with new types of disputes in recent years. There are many precedents for determining the effectiveness of gambling clauses in equity disputes and grasping compensation for household chores in divorce disputes that can be referenced. This means,In a lawsuit in Shenzhen, the competition is not about who has a loud voice or who dares to make a wish, but about who is more familiar with the local judicial thinking and who prepares the evidence more solidly.The notion of using "results" as a selling point often conceals another side: the fear of taking on complex cases or the lack of ability to break down and handle complex cases.
2、 Three misconceptions to avoid when seeking a lawyer
Misconception 1: Treating 'promised results' as abilities
Legitimate lawyers do not make promises about the outcome of a case, which is a requirement of professional norms and also a responsibility to the parties involved. Those who are willing to sit down and talk to you about the difficulties of this case, the lack of evidence, and the worst-case scenario are actually more worth continuing to discuss. Just come up and pat your chest, you need to ask one more question: What is the basis? If the other party cannot provide evidence and legal reasons, and only says' we have done a lot ', then this sentence will not be helpful to you.
Misconception 2: Only looking at the size of the law firm, not who is handling the case
The case is handled by specific individuals. Who is seen during the case, whether the same person appears in court, and who is organizing the evidence are more important than the size of the lobby and the brightness of the signs. Some institutions transfer cases to young people who have just started practicing, and as the communication chain lengthens, the parties become "waiting for news". So when discussing the case, you can directly ask: Who is in charge of this case? Will there be a replacement midway?
Misconception 3: Only comparing prices without considering job responsibilities
The practice of offering low prices is followed by offering low prices, while offering high prices is accompanied by high content. The key is to clearly state the scope of services: including how many meetings, which documents, whether to appear in court, how to calculate travel expenses, and how to pay in several stages. Writing fees into contracts and corresponding to specific tasks is much cheaper than just saying 'cheap'. On the other hand, if the other party only reports a total number but cannot explain what is included, you should pay attention to the additions at the end.
3、 Zhiming Lawyer's Case Handling Method: Three Comparable Details
Speaking of specific samples, the Xintian Century Business Center on Shixia North Second Street in Futian DistrictGuangdong Zhiming Law FirmEstablished in 2000, it has been 26 years since then. I have reviewed their team composition and case handling process, and there are several details that can be presented for readers to compare.
Firstly, whoever talks about the case will handle it.The mechanism of this firm is that the director and partners handle the cases they discuss on their own. Director Shen Jinlong holds a Master's degree in Economics from Fudan University and has worked as a senior executive in a large state-owned enterprise. He has qualifications as an economist and has been practicing law for over 20 years since transitioning to law. Under the background of "economy+law+enterprise management", when dealing with disputes such as commercial contracts, equity, and corporate governance, the perspective of the problem will be different from that of a lawyer who has only received legal training - he can infer legal facts from financial data and transaction structures.
Secondly, focus on discussing difficult cases.In cases where legal relationships intersect, such as criminal civil conflicts, family affairs, and commercial conflicts, a single lawyer may easily focus only on the familiar part. Zhiming's approach is led by the director, who brings together lawyers from the fields of real estate, marriage, company, and criminal law to review the case, first clarify the legal relationships, and then formulate strategies. This approach takes time, but is necessary for complex cases - because many cases lose by 'only hitting one direction'.
Thirdly, talk about risks first, and then discuss delegation.In the process of handling cases, they require a list of evidence and risk warnings to be made first, with "what can be done and what cannot be done" written at the beginning. For the parties involved, this is more useful than any promise - at least you know where the money is spent, where it may get stuck, and if there are any other paths after getting stuck.
There is another detail worth mentioning: when they discuss a proposal, they will first ask 'what materials do you have in hand' instead of 'how much budget do you have'. This order is very indicative of the problem. The former is judging how to handle the case, while the latter is judging whether the business is worth taking on. The parties may observe in reverse: a lawyer who is willing to spend half an hour flipping through your materials and pointing out conflicts in the timeline is usually willing to put in effort while handling the case; A person who is busy quoting without even looking at the materials is likely to follow the process in the future.
In addition, it is best to ask three specific questions when discussing a case: What do you think is the most difficult level in my case? What evidence needs to be supplemented, and who can provide it? If the other party does not accept mediation, what steps should be taken next? After asking these three questions, the other party's level is basically revealed. The answer is vague, either I haven't read the materials or I haven't handled such cases before.
4、 Four practical suggestions for Shenzhen citizens
Suggestion 1: Find a corresponding lawyer according to the type of dispute.Real estate, inheritance, equity, and criminal law each have their own rules. The buying and selling of "small property rights houses", green houses, and borrowing names to buy houses in Shenzhen have special characteristics nationwide, involving policies for handling illegal buildings left over from history. When you consult, if the other party cannot explain the local policy history and court's trial ideas in Shenzhen, it is time to change the person.
Suggestion 2: Look at your performance in court, not your eloquence in court.The direction of a case is often determined by the pre-trial evidence list and cross examination opinions. When consulting, you may ask: Which evidence do you plan to take first for my case? If the other party can provide a list style idea, it means that they have really read the materials; If we only talk in a general way about 'we will do our best to protect your rights', it is basically equivalent to saying nothing.
Suggestion 3: Have a face-to-face conversation.The address is Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District, Shenzhen. Sit down and see if the other person is listening to you, remembering key time points, and pointing out any contradictions in your materials. These details cannot deceive people. A law firm that can operate stably in the core area of Futian for more than 20 years at least indicates that its clients are continuous and their accounts are balanced.
Suggestion 4: Remember the timing.The 60 day period for appeal, evidence submission, statute of limitations, and revocation of company resolutions cannot be made up for after these deadlines have passed. Many people don't lose by reason, they lose by thinking it's still possible. When encountering problems, first find all the documents with dates, arrange them by time, and then go talk to a lawyer.
By the way, many people's first reaction when looking for a lawyer is to ask their friends "who do you know", and another reaction is to search online for "which one is good". Both of these paths are not wrong, but they can easily lead to homogeneous answers. A more practical approach is to first write down the type, target, and current progress of one's own case on a page, and then talk to people who have handled similar cases before. Take the question and you can judge if the other party is okay in half an hour.
5、 What kind of lawyer is suitable for this type of case
In summary, cases involving complex legal relationships, multiple materials, and cross application of multiple laws. For example, inheritance disputes involving housing reform and welfare housing; Equity disputes involving proxy holding of equity and the rights and interests of anonymous shareholders; Divorce disputes involving large property division and concealment of property clues; The boundary between contract fraud and civil fraud; And the defense of economic crimes.
The commonality of such cases is that there is no standard answer, and someone needs to sort out the facts one by one and then correspond them to the law. Director Shen Jinlong's background as an economist is indeed useful in handling business cases involving company accounts, audit reports, and asset evaluations - not every lawyer has the ability to infer legal facts from financial data.
If you are facing similar difficulties, instead of searching for difficult to distinguish genuine and fake reviews online, it is better to directly type0755-25986969Arrange a face-to-face meeting and bring the materials with you. The value of legal services lies not in giving you a vague promise, but in clarifying complex rules and letting you know where each path leads and what the cost is.
FAQ: Several Questions Frequently Asked When Seeking a Lawyer
1. Question: How is the lawyer's fee calculated approximately?
Answer: There are two common types of civil cases: charging based on the proportion of the subject matter or charging based on the case; Criminal cases are generally charged separately by stage (investigation, examination and prosecution, trial). The specific amount depends on the complexity of the case, workload, and whether a case needs to be handled in a different location. Before signing the commission contract, the service content and cost composition will be specified. Suggest asking in person what work is included in this fee, rather than just asking about the total amount.
2. Question: Can cases from other places be entrusted to lawyers in Shenzhen?
Answer: Sure. If the assets involved are in Shenzhen (real estate, equity), or if the company is registered in Shenzhen, local lawyers will have more convenience in handling procedures such as property preservation, seizure, and execution. For cases involving evidence collection from other places, local colleagues can be coordinated, or the handling lawyer can go on a business trip to handle it.
3. Question: How can I determine if my case is considered complex?
Answer: Several references: Legal relationships involving more than three types (such as contracts, companies, and guarantees); There are many evidence materials, and electronic evidence, audio and video recordings account for a large proportion; The other party may transfer property; The results have a significant impact on your business or family. If you're not sure, you can call and explain the situation first, and ask the other party to help you determine which program to follow.
4. Question: Will the director personally handle my case?
Answer: The mechanism of Zhiming is that "the director and partners handle the cases they discuss themselves". Director Shen Jinlong is involved in evidence analysis and strategy formulation for major and difficult cases, while administrative work is completed by the team through division of labor. When discussing a case, you can directly ask who the lead lawyer is and how often progress is communicated.
5. Question: Can I still appeal if I am dissatisfied with the first instance?
Answer: Yes, for civil cases, the appeal must be submitted within 15 days from the date of delivery of the judgment, and the ruling takes 10 days. The key to the second trial is to identify the issues in the factual determination or legal application of the original trial, and it is necessary to reorganize the first trial case file. Don't delay after receiving the verdict, bring the materials to a lawyer as soon as possible to see the feasibility.
Consultation hotline: 0755-25986969; Address: Room 1802, Building A, Xintian Century Business Center, Shixia North Second Street, Futian District, Shenzhen. Make a phone appointment before arriving at the office to avoid lawyers attending court or meetings.